Showing posts with label review: Church in the Present Tense. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review: Church in the Present Tense. Show all posts

25 May 2011

church in the present tense 4/4

Scot McKnight, Peter Rollins, Kevin J. Corcoran, Jason Clark.Church in the Present Tense: A Candid Look at What's Emerging. Grand Rapids: Brazos Press, 2011.

This review is divided into four parts, one for each major section of the book. Here we discuss Part Three: Bible and Doctrine.

The final two chapters of the book are authored by our friend over at The Jesus Creed, Scot McKnight.

Chapter Seven is entitled, "Scripture in the Emerging Movement." It begins with a bit of autobiographical background to explain McKnight's entrance into the emerging church discussion. As his blog discussions and his placement in this book demonstrate, he has become one of the more significant voices in the present discussion. (I think this is the case because he is willing to both commend and critique other voices in the movement, based not on sentiment or desire but on truth.) Regarding the questions surrounding emergent: "What attracted me? The willingness to question things, even sacred things. The desire to get Christianity back on track with Jesus's vision for the kingdom" (106).

The remainder of Chapter Seven is thus designed as a miniature introduction to the identifiable methodologies of approaching and applying Scripture from emergent groups. To accomplish this he leans heavily on his larger (and outstanding) book, The Blue Parakeet (2008). Those who are unfamiliar with the book will find the chapter to be a good introduction to the larger discussion. Those who have read the book will most likely shift into a skimming mode through a lot of the chapter.

Following the brief discussion on how the Bible is read (and noting that there does not exist a single type of reading among the emergent groups (111)), McKnight does draw some fresh conclusions and even issues some warnings to the new movements within the church. One such is quite appropriate for Christians of any stripe: ". . . commitment to the linguistic turn and its profound impact on hermeneutics and Bible reading dare not lead to arrogance. It leads one to drink form a well that cannot be drained, to an ocean that is too vast for words, and to a God who is so distant and holy and unapproachable that reverence is the only proper entailment of an emerging understanding of Scripture" (114).

Yet, in support of the movement which introduces diversity into hermeneutic he writes, "No single story, not even Jesus's, can tell the whole story. We need them all" (117). It is imperative to recapture the context of Scripture, with all of its twists and turns, and apply it to ourselves in the same way it was intended. This is a point which is built upon in the final chapter as well.

Chapter Eight is simply titled, "Atonement and Gospel," and is one of the best offerings in the entire book. Mostly I say this because it seeks to read Scripture in context as a means of cutting through layers of theological discussion that are more grounded in philosophical-theological thought than in the biblical text. There is a good amount of effort in the front half of the chapter devoted to understanding the concept of gospel in contemporary usage. Biblical studies have shown how this term is quite different in first century contexts than in contemporary ones, and McKnight applies the discussion well to the state of the church.

This discussion leads McKnight to examine Acts, for he believes that ". . . none of these atonement theories is at work in any central manner in the gospel preaching of the book of Acts. Something else is at work" (131). Herein lies the other piece of high value to this chapter - its survey of the first century church's message as demonstrated in Acts. This is driven by a response to the notion that, "Atonement theories are driving the meaning of gospel" (129).

Eight points are given to draw out the emphases of gospel preaching in the book of Acts, guiding the reader towards the notion of story as gospel. Simply stated, the early church told the story of Israel and the story of Jesus as a way of explaining the impact of messianic death, resurrection and exaltation. That story was not weighed by theory, but was told as a new reality which has broken into the world. McKnight suggests we return to that as a starting point in the church's (both emerging and otherwise) proclamation (cf. 138).

Having spent much time and energy in exploring the New Testament texts and contexts, I must say that I strongly agree with McKnight's analysis here. This chapter goes further in presenting that material in a manner relevant to today's church.

18 May 2011

church in the present tense 3/4

Scot McKnight, Peter Rollins, Kevin J. Corcoran, Jason Clark.Church in the Present Tense: A Candid Look at What's Emerging. Grand Rapids: Brazos Press, 2011.

This review is divided into four parts, one for each major section of the book. Here we discuss Part Three: Worship.

Jason Clark once again provides a chapter, this time on "The Renewal of Liturgy in the Emerging Church." Chapter Five comes as a critique of current evangelicalism and the place that liturgy has within our modern worship. There is much to be said regarding the state of worship today, with a great amount of shallowing in individual faith because of a collapse of corporate tradition.

Clark writes, "Without a recovery and understanding of liturgy we are in danger of a collapse of ecclesiology and church into solipsistic worship aesthetics and private spaces" (75). Perhaps you are intimidated by that sentence. Let me paraphrase: We as churchgoers either enter into the larger narrative of our faith or we turn this into an elaborate enterprise of worshipping our own desires. Clark continues later, "We are whatever we want to be. We make ourselves in an image of our own manufacture. Often the selves we create are shallow and superficial, as they are based on issues of taste, personal preference, or whatever makes us happy" (80).

This is the sad and stark reality that our worship resembles, and I think that Jason Clark has made observations which are quite accurate. But his essay is not intended to simply decry the failures of the current practices of the church. Instead, his critique is intended to move forward to a more comprehensive and complete form of worship. He states, "Liturgy and ritual open up the possibility of reconnecting beliefs to their origins and to the people who held and practiced them generations ago. They connect us to the past, to the story, and shape us for life together in an alien world" . . . "We live in a world that does not know what to do with the ordinary"(81).

Following this discussion Clark introduces Flow: A Short-Term Catechism which came out of his own emergent church community. The notion is compared to a short-term missions experience, but through which the experience is replicated to one's own life and work on a daily basis. It is a forty day commitment to take one's faith into a secular world. It is built on three key elements: doing, knowing, being. It is worth taking a closer look, for certain, and contains the seeds of missional living for all believers.

Chapter Six is written by Peter Rollins, "Transformance Art: Reconfiguring the Social Self." Admittedly, there were some philosophical comments early on in this chapter that were a small challenge to distill . . . (especially when one begins to quote the writings of Karl Marx). However, I think that Rollins is on an interesting path with the early comment, "The ironic stance can be described as a way of distancing oneself from a certain social activity while simultaneously engaging in it" (90). Further, he says it this way, "The ironic stance can be maintained through engaging in what we may call perverse transgression. A perverse transgression is any act that appears to undermine a particular system but that actually affirms the very system it purports to attack" (92).

Rollins' point here is that Christian belief is often contradictory in what testimony comes from our mouths in comparison to what testimony flows from our lives. And the emerging generations of believers are unwilling to perpetuate such a system. It is simply unacceptable that we should talk about injustice and then participate in activities which make injustice more prevalent in the world. To this, Rollins asks, "To what extent can our prayer meetings and weekly commitment to the poor actually be the very activities that enable us to engage in careers that help to perpetuate what we are praying against?" (94).

Is it more important to defend our own culture and socio-traditions or follow the radical demands of the kingdom of God? If it is the latter, then the former must be removed . . . a complete transformation of the self over a 'better version' of the self. In one of the most quotable passages in the book thus far, "Christianity promises not intellectual satisfaction but rather substantive transformation, that is, a qualitative change in our being that reconfigures our way of being in the world" (97).

Although I don't readily understand or jump on board with the notions of what Rollins calls Transformance Art, I think that I ultimately grab hold of his underlying notion. Where I agree is that the individual (and community) who is transformed by the Spirit of God ought to also identify a renewal of the world around them, at least the potential renewal of it through the ongoing work of the Spirit from within. It is heaven that has come into the person and now seeks to move outward in a transformation of all creation.

The section on Worship should not be taken lightly, for it is a dimension of our lives that we worship. Whether it is a healthy worship of our Creator or a destructive worship of ourselves and our stuff, we must examine the context within which our devotion occurs.

04 May 2011

church in the present tense 2/4

Scot McKnight, Peter Rollins, Kevin J. Corcoran, Jason Clark.Church in the Present Tense: A Candid Look at What's Emerging. Grand Rapids: Brazos Press, 2011.

This review is divided into four parts, one for each major section of the book. Here we discuss Part Two: Theology.

Chapter Three is "Consumer Liturgies and Their Corrosive Effects on Christian Identity" by Jason Clark. It is an outstanding essay on the current status of the church and the responses being given by the emergent community. Identifying cultural shifts which no longer have Christianity at the center of the community he explains that his own emergent experience was around a new set of questions, "Our question became not, how do we do church better so that people do not leave? but, how do we recover church for our context?" (39).

Cutting to the heart of the matter, and indeed many frustrations shared by those currently immersed in the church traditions, Clark writes, "Indeed, church has become nothing more than a meaningless expression of private religious association or a private club. But what if church were not just one choice among many but an ultimate and final choice?" (43). Clark's is a summons to move beyond consumerism in the life of the church in an effort to discover the life-changing renewal which is found in conformity with Christ.

Along this line of thinking Clark also ponders what a church that is more conformed to Christ would begin to be: "What if there is a 'givenness' to ecclesiology and church, a givenness in which we find our identity in contrast to the endless self-creation of identity of the modern consumer agent?" (45). These are lofty ideals indeed, but ones that seem to be embedded in the hearts of emergent Christians. Yet before the reader can fall into an ethereal conceptualization of the *perfect church* the author gives this important perspective, "I just want to be part of a 'real church,' we might cry out of exasperation. Perhaps we have been part of real churches already but have simply failed to notice" (48).

Having greatly appreciated the words in this essay, especially with the doses of imperfect realities throughout, I think Clark has contributed well to the conversation. I might echo Roger Olson's critique that perhaps some more concrete answers could have been included. This is but a minor quibble, though.

Chapter Four is "Thy Kingdom Come (on Earth): An Emerging Eschatology" by Kevin Corcoran. At the beginning of his thought he identifies this trend: "Emerging folks are, it seems, an eschatological lot, people who seek to make God's future a present reality, as best they can" (59). This, however, is not the eschatology of rapture and pre-post-a-Left Behind-millenialism that has been a part of the previous generation of the church. Rather, this is a future-made-present understanding of the kingdom of God, being the impetus of missional work.

This sort of approach makes it rather obvious why Tom Wright has become the unofficial patron saint of emergent Christianity. Corcoran writes, "Heaven is here, now, embodied in earth and mud. Granted, this kingdom has not yet been consummated or fully actualized. Still, it is here and it is now. It is a kingdom come and still coming" (65). This type of reality - one that makes the Lordship of Christ and the experience of his people presently meaningful - has given a renewed vigor to the emerging generation of Christians, as well as a breath of fresh air into our congregations.

27 April 2011

church in the present tense 1/4

Scot McKnight, Peter Rollins, Kevin J. Corcoran, Jason Clark.Church in the Present Tense: A Candid Look at What's Emerging. Grand Rapids: Brazos Press, 2011.

What has been missing from the emerging church movement is a solid academic presentation and critique of its trends and ideals. I have often found myself frustrated in finding a coherent and comprehensive system of thought in much of what has been said and written about the movement. In fact, it often feels as though the concept of 'emergent' might be a breath of fresh airstylistically in the worship of the church, but theologically (or philosophically) it is a bit of a mess.

This is why I am interested in the current book, and want to spend some time interacting with it. Brazos Press has produced a volume that appears to have helped the conversation along quite nicely. The method of review and discussion here will be in four parts (one for each section of the book): Philosophy, Theology, Worship, Bible and Doctrine.

Part One: Philosophy

Chapter One is on the question, "Who's Afraid of Philosophical Realism? Taking Emerging Christianity to Task" by Kevin Corcoran. Admittedly, some of the upfront material is a bit philosophical in its writing style and will undoubtedly be a challenge to many readers, specifically many pastors who have not engaged in a philosophy course for some time. Nevertheless it is a good chapter.

One of the foundational points that Corcoran makes is that there is a role-reversal in the divine-human relationship: "Instead of recognizing God as our Creator and responding to him as such, we keep fashioning him into whatever role we need him to be playing at the moment" (7). Thus, approaching a real and living faith needs to be reevaluated.

Also in play in this essay is the question of postmodernity. I wholeheartedly agree with the author that this is one of the most overused and least understood terms in modern discussions of philosophy and (especially) theology (cf. 13). Hence, Corcoran goes on to establish a viable definition of postmodernism (which I was already tired of about ten years ago!). I remember my philosophy instructor (William Hasker) explaining that we cannot adequately define postmodernism as a philosophical movement because we do not have the ability to see it for what it is - beginning to end. The actual term only implies that we are now moving out of modernity into something else. So it would be wise to be patient and see what happens.

In this same tenor, Corcoran arrives at the following, "The postmodern turn for Christians is, therefore, a turn away from Christianity as believing or knowing certain things and a turn toward Christianity as opening oneself up to a transformative event" (14). He thus sees Christian faith in the postmodern understanding as a movement fundamentally built upon spiritual formation and connected to the long traditions of spiritual practices (cf. 15). The reality of the Christian journey is, therefore, the process of becoming (sort of a Kierkegaardian idea, I think), which leads the author here to say that he is constantly at the beginning of his faith (cf. 17).

Chapter Two is offered by Peter Rollins on "The Worldly Theology of Emerging Christianity." It is a solid discussion on the uniqueness of the Christian message, utilizing much Pauline thought to get his point across. Central to the argument is the notion that the church is a group that is completely distinct from all others. He puts it in a great perspective: "Instead of writing about both Jews and Greeks, slaves and free, men and women, he writes of a new identity in Christ, one that cuts across political, cultural, and biological divisions, one that involves the laying down of such identities" (23). That is to say, it is no longer a both-and of personal identification and Christian belief, it is an either-or of belonging to the world or to the kingdom narrative.

Turning this thought further on its head, Rollins asks what Paul's thought would look like if the gospel was able to transform (or call into question) the social distinctions that encompass us (cf. 25). In this line of thought he includes an interpretive semi-translation of Paul's famous Galatians 3 statement, which is interesting but makes me wonder about some of the categories listed. On a logical level why would there be both theist and atheist who have faith in Christ Jesus? I think he is going for a rather Inclusivist position here, but it reads awkwardly.

Further on this is the inclusion of his statement, "[neither] gay nor straight" which is a difficult button to push here. How far can we take such inclusion? This is not to condemn any who are homosexual, nor is it to say that it should be considered more of a sin than any other. But, on the other hand, homosexuality should not be considered more acceptable than any other behavior. Where are we allowed to draw the lines of this community if it is automatically all-inclusive without a call to leave one's sin? (Nor do I think this as a matter of God's special preference for those who are marginalized by society.)

With this piece out the way, I must say that the remainder of the essay raises some great points. One of Rollins' central points is that, ". . . to identify with Christ means to acknowledge that it is not the ultimate horizon" (25). Certainly this is a key point to understanding the faith. Salvation, after all, is not the end . . . it is the means to an end within God's kingdom-coming. And, yes, Rollins is correct in saying that identification with Christ means shaking ourselves free from the socio-cultural baggage we carry with us (cf. 26).

Even though I don't see all of the proposals following through, there is a strong philosophical foundation set here for approaching postmodern and/or emerging Christianity in a thoughtful way. It will be interesting to see how the theological perspectives (Part Two) continue to build on this.