Showing posts with label recovering pharisees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recovering pharisees. Show all posts

07 April 2010

recovering pharisees 5: galilean influence

Opinions regarding the Pharisees abound, and trying to get at them has traditionally been difficult. Yet, in the past few years a good amount of light has been shed on this highly influential group, and many previous ideas have been abandoned. What has become clear to the historian is that the Pharisees are anything but clearly understood figures; they are a complex group, which means things aren't as quickly black-and-white as so many would prefer. Indeed, understanding them properly not only takes a good amount of work, but it also challenges our readings of the gospel narrative.

Craig S. Keener, The Historical Jesus of the Gospels (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2009).

In his recent book, Craig Keener briefly explores Jesus' relationship with the Pharisees and their conflicts. In the process he also provides good information on the identity of the Pharisees as well, a few of which are worth mention here - especially for those who've not spent much time getting to know this first century Jewish sect.

One of the opening 'concessions' which Keener provides is that the Pharisees were probably rare in Galilee (cf. 224). This statement comes from source information found in Josephus, who focuses on the Pharisaic activity in Jerusalem. Of course, his omission can't be taken as completely exclusive, but the point which we gain from this is that the center of debate and activity during this time period was in Jerusalem. It fits with the overall historical picture that Galilee was an out-of-the-way region without prominence. But, the question still remains (Keener does not address it, as his focus is on the adult conflicts between Jesus and the Pharisees) on how much influence the Pharisaic movement would have held into various regions.

Scholars have observed for some time that the Pharisaic influence was strong, though I would begin to question just how much in light of our increasing knowledge of other emerging Jewish traditions within the Second Temple period. Nevertheless, we are on safe ground to assume that most people would have self-identified with either the Pharisaic or Enochic traditions in this period, even though very few individuals had the time or opportunity to officially participate in any sect.

My point is this, although we might concede with Keener that there was a lacking physical presence of the Pharisees in Galilee (and that the conflicts are most likely those coming from Jerusalem to investigate this charismatic teacher and healer), we must not discount the spiritual influence which this group would have held over this region (as well as other regions). I agree with Keener that Jesus was not likely a Pharisee (185), but I do think that it is probable that he had Pharisaic influence given to him during his life in Galilee, a trickle-down from the 'official' work of the Pharisaic debate in Jerusalem.

I think that we observe similar phenomena in our own culture when theological positions find their ways into generations and locations which are quite disconnected from their source. How many times do I find snippets of dispensationalism on lay-interpretations of Revelation by people who would otherwise never hold to such a theological position? Most likely it is due to great-grandpa's Bible, which was an original Scofield taken at face value and never questioned from that point forward. Right or wrong, it wasn't passed down as responsible theology but as heritage . . . and it moved outward as time passed. Similarly, influence from the 'official' Pharisaic sect probably held influence on Galilee.

Another 'caveat' worth mentioning from Keener is appropriate here: ". . . the Pharisees did not go around trying to kill or even arrest people who differed from their interpretation of the law - at least not in this period" (224). It is always important to remember that all of the debates that we have in the Second Temple period (including Jesus' own conflicts with Jewish groups) were internal debates within Judaism. That should color our view in an important way, so that we understand the strong bond of implied unity which the Jewish people possessed.

Here we find the seeds of Jesus' exclusion from this community and the call for his death, but that discussion will be reserved for another time.

20 May 2009

recovering pharisees 4: temple and torah

John P. Meier, A Marginal Jew (v 3): Companions and Competitors (New York: Doubleday, 2001).

In the third of his four-volume work on the historical Jesus, John Meier surveys the competing voices which make up part of Jesus' context (largely devoted to the Pharisees, Sadducees and Essenes). A clipping out of his comments on the Pharisees says, "The struggle between Jesus (or early Christians) and the Pharisees over questions of law reflects a wider struggle raging in Israel around the turn of the era over the proper interpretation of the Mosaic Law" (315). It has been established well (not least in this series of posts) that the issue with Pharisees comes down to Torah interpretation and resulting practice. Meier goes on to assert the two greatest unifying and divisive symbols in Second Temple Judaism to be Temple and Torah (315), and a picture of the Pharisaic sect would be incomplete without hovering over this notion for a brief moment.

Before that, however, I do wish to address the notion that the four gospel narratives contain more retrojected debate-points than actual historical conflict. Meier assumes this, along with many other who are closer to 'mainline' scholarship, but has failed to provide any solid reasons why this must be the case. While appreciate the breadth of his work, this appears to be a major overstep in the process - it is assumed rather than addressed - something which should be inserted if it is deemed a major piece of his argument. The problem that I have with such notions is that it makes the early Christian community appear more concerned with winning debates than preserving the salvation story. All while proclaiming and suffering and dying for a story which

The issues of Temple and Torah is case-in-point, but here Meier prefers to handle the issue rather than relegate it to a later debate. Jesus and the Pharisees not only differed on Torah interpretation but also on their understanding of Temple (here we would do well to defer to NTW's JVG). Temple refers not simply to a building, but rather to the Jewish covenant as a whole in practice. The debates of Pharisee, Sadducee, and everyone else comes down to the current state of the covenant, not some abstract ideology or theology. Temple and Torah thus work hand in hand to bring about the covenant blessings of God. Fitting Jesus into this is somewhat different than commonly assumed - his challenge was to the leadership of Israel, who directed the covenant story away from its intended goal.

To round out Meier's take: "In my view, what made the Pharisees distinctive was that they openly admitted that some of their legal views and practices were not to be found as such in the written Mosaic Law, that such practices were instead venerable 'traditions' that had been handed down by the 'fathers' or the 'elders,' and that such practices nevertheless were God's will for all Israel" (315).

22 October 2008

recovering pharisees 3: unengaged visible holiness

Amy-Jill Levine, "Luke's Pharisees" in Jacob Neusner and Bruce D. Chilton, eds., In Quest of the Historical Pharisees (Waco: Baylor University Press, 2007), 113-130.

Probably the most significant contribution which emerges from Levine's essay on the Pharisees in Luke-Acts is that she challenges many preconceptions which the reader brings to the text.  Sometimes her argument is more convincing than others but, on a whole, she does a solid job of this.  Whether or not she is able to reconstruct an accurate understanding of the sect is difficult to say - some will clearly think she has while others doubt her presentation.

From a literary (and theological) standpoint, Levine believes that Luke includes the Pharisees in his gospel in order to enhance Jesus' role in the narrative (115).  There is a sense in which I can accept this as true, but it doesn't account for the whole of their function (and she might not have even gone that route, given a more developed conversation on this point).  But the Pharisees are representative for Luke (and the other gospel narratives) of the primary ideology during Second Temple Judaism - a strong voice from within the common narrative of God's people in exile.  In this sense, she would be correct; but not if we see this enhancement as simple straw-manning for the sake of setting up Jesus.

Of special issue in the Gospel of Luke is that Jesus shares table fellowship with the Pharisees - which means that there must have been some level of acceptance into the Pharisaic community (cf. 120).  This is an interesting point, as it muddies the waters of separation which evangelicals have typically placed between Jesus and the Pharisees.  But the narrative suggests otherwise, that these were individuals who were concerned with the holiness of Israel but who too often did not follow through on their commitment to this end.

What is at stake, therefore, is Torah interpretation (cf. 122f.).  The focus lies on the approach to understanding Torah which has been taken by Jesus and the Pharisees - how do we take the Hebrew Scriptures and apply them to daily life?  This is connected (in Levine's article) to the parable of the Prodigal Son, where the primary issue becomes the willingness to seek out sinners: Jesus is willing to do so, the Pharisees are not (cf. 126).  We do see, however, a constant Pharisaic presence within the nation of Israel: they do not simply remove themselves from the ritual impurity of the population.  Rather, they maintain their visible presence in Israel even though they are not reaching out to the impurity around them.

If we are to maintain the thesis of this multi-part study which claims that the Pharisees are the closest equivalent to modern evangelicals, then we must consider whether or not our interpretation of Scripture is flawed.  I believe we find our clearest point of connection here within the visible presence of evangelical Christians, even when there is very little outreach happening.  To what end were the Pharisees interpreting?  It may be too difficult to make an historical conclusion on this.  But modern evangelicals are interpreting for their own sense of salvation and security, benefit and blessing.  This is how we have become Pharisaic in our contemporary culture.

17 September 2008

recovering pharisees 2: paths to power

There is an interesting essay by Martin Pickup entitled, "Matthew's and Mark's Pharisees" in Jacob Neusner and Bruce D. Chilton, eds., In Quest of the Historical Pharisees (Waco: Baylor University Press, 2007), 67-112. As part of his chapter, Pickup provides an analysis of the Pharisees in Jewish society.

Especially within Mark's gospel, the Pharisees are not presented as having any sort of political power or authority - or even 'holding religious office' (71). Throughout the narrative they must join together with the Herodians in trying to take care of the Jesus situation. This means, I believe, that while they are not happy about Israel's position of exile under the Roman government they nevertheless must find ways to work with the system in order to get what they want. It is a peculiar situation which reflects much of our world today - proving again my assertion that we are not as far from the Pharisees as we would have ourselves believe.

Notice that this is evident in that the Pharisees 'have no direct involvement in Jesus' arrest and trial' (71). Somehow, Jesus' most constant source of criticism and opposition fade away when the story arrives at its climax. This could be because Jesus and the Pharisees were really about the same idea - the restoration of Israel - although they differed greatly in their interpretation of Torah. The sacrifice of atonement was never questioned throughout the gospel, although additional laws of ritual were often at the forefront of controversy.

Further, although they are a very visible sect of purity and righteousness, the Pharisees are not presented as having any control over the synagogues (cf. 71). Their influence seems to come from their visible dedication to Torah and purity, often initiating the right discussions among the right people at the right times in steering the ship of Israel's restoration. But then they are able to get out of the way of the political and military machine which they will denounce as standing in the way of Israel's vindication.

The Pharisees' power seems to come from their voice - the ability to rouse public opinion and focus on matters which they deem important for the nation. This is not too far from many evangelicals, who have used the fellowship of the saints as a means for advancing various agendas which may or may not reflect sound biblical doctrine. And this is done to the division of the church, for it draws lines which make it quite difficult to accept a brother or sister in Christ through the haze of activism. And, when the need for true atonement arrives, they are the first ones fading into the woodwork.

31 July 2008

recovering pharisees 1: the פורשימ

In the recently released book: David Flusser, Judaism of the Second Temple Period: Volume 1, Qumran and Apocalypticism (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2007), there is a good article entitled "4QMMT and the Benediction Against the Minim" which includes a brief overview of the societal divisions within Second Temple Judaism. Of particular interest is the Pharisaic sect, a group which (I believe) resembles modern evangelicalism more than any other in Scripture. Thus it is of particular interest to understand this movement and why Jesus was opposed to them so often. (Hint: it is not because they were 'bad' and he was 'good' and we are most certainly on his side, so he can't possibly be talking about us.)

What Flusser points out in his essay is that the name itself began with negative connotations, which were meant as a condemnation of the movement itself - one which the Pharisees could not escape and eventually adopted as their own: "More importantly, the rabbinic Sages came to be called פורשימ, and. . .they were unhappy with this epithet on account of its negative connotations" (93). The charge in question comes from the within the Dead Sea Scrolls (see the title of the article), and is meant to speak against those who separate themselves from the true people of Israel.

It is intriguing, however, that the Qumran sect most certainly were separatist while at the same time condemning those who were separating! The difference is found in the Essene belief that they themselves were the true Israel coming away from apostate Israel. This means that the Pharisees were separating themselves from the true Israel by their actions - in that they were no longer representative of the mission of Israel. Historically, that there was no separatism among the Pharisees demonstrates their ability to capture the popular theological opinion and voice of the day, thus ". . .shaping the course of Jewish history" (98).

Eventually, the primary charge against the Pharisees was that of hypocrisy (cf. 100) - by the Essenes and Sadducess and, most famously, Matthew 23. The case of Jesus is interesting, in that he acknowledges their teaching as coming from the seat of Moses but yet challenges their ability to live it out - an existing authority coming from Scripture, but a failing example. The charge in this situation is that while their words might carry truth, their lives are failure.

In relation to modern evangelicalism, the situation regarding the Pharisees demonstrates the ways in which sub-groups of believers interact with others. The fact that the Pharisees held to a high view of Scripture yet chose to separate themselves from other factions of Israel, yet claim to speak for the whole of Israel is not far from many within the church. It seems that unity among disagreement in the church is not often possible, because we are too quick to ignore or separate from those with whom we may disagree. At the same time, it seems that each group claims exclusivity to the *true* doctrines of God - and that others are apostate.

Addressing the situation outwardly, the church often looks like Pharisees to the world: those who separate themselves (often in stupid or pointless ways), leading to characterizations which are negative but eventually accurate. The die has been cast, but will the end be the same?