Showing posts with label judaism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label judaism. Show all posts

06 August 2011

a more profound essenism

It has become commonplace within the world of biblical studies to equate Qumran with the Essene movement as a whole. While there are some deep connections between the two, the oversimplification with which they have been treated is misleading our understanding of the diversity of Second Temple Judaism. We have not adequately understood Essenism as it existed in ancient Judaism.

One of the best books to help uncover this, and point us in a better direction, is Gabriel Boccaccini's Beyond the Essene Hypothesis (Eerdmans, 1998). And because a consensus for Second Temple Judaism is still being sought, the need to reexamine the data is high. This examination is especially needed by those in the world of biblical studies who have had little exposure to the wider Second Temple literature. Yes, it is a daunting scope of writing, but it is the fuller context of the world of the Jesus movement - we need context to understand history.

So, what's the deal with Essenism?

First, Josephus tells us that they were not confined to one particular city but rather had a presence throughout Israel (Jewish War 2.124). And while we may consider the sectarian community at Qumran a part of the Essene movement, we must confess that it is a matter of historical record that they were much more than the desert-dwellers. There are some competing theories to the nature of the division between Qumran and the larger Essene tradition, but for now we will leave it as a subdivision of the same overall movement.

Boccaccini's text demonstrates a plausible history based upon the available texts that shows an Enochic tradition which later develops into Essenism, which then includes a break of the Qumran community. But Essenism continues on even with Qumran to the side.

Second, scholars increasingly express the popularity of the texts associated with the Enochic-Essene tradition, especially the five-fold work of 1 Enoch. Many of these texts are present in the wider expressions of Essenism - even though some may be seen as sectarian and kept within Qumran. With such a widely popular group of writings that were not confined to a desert community but present throughout all Israel, we should not think for a moment that Jesus and his early followers were not influenced by them. The questions for us are How and How Far.

Boccaccini's work helps give a sense of these texts and leads to some interesting thoughts about the emerging Jesus movement. And he just might be on to something here. Though I don't include it in specific quite yet, some of the teachings in the Enochic-Essene tradition are surprisingly similar to things we find in the early church and gospel.

There is a lot of attention given to the Hellenistic influences upon the early church. Much of this is good research and insightful study. But we must also consider the context of Second Temple Judaism, which helped define life for ancient Israel and continued for about forty of the first years of the church. Hence, we must be more diligent in reading the Second Temple Jewish literature, remaining open-minded enough to shift our understanding of how what we read in the Gospels are influenced by such a context.

14 July 2009

re:creation in daniel 7

Cf. James D. G. Dunn, Jesus Remembered. Christianity in the Making, Vol. 1 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003), 729f.

In the first volume of Dunn's exploration into the origins of Christianity he briefly covers the quite important Daniel 7, one of the primary texts behind Israel's restoration and messianic concepts. This chapter has been combed over many times before, not just by the kooks with end-times charts and television programs, but by biblical scholars who recognize the importance of this passage to understand more fully the gospel narratives. Dunn's assertion in this volume is that Daniel 7 is told with the creation narratives in mind: that the scene unfolding in apocalyptic narrative is based upon the Jewish telling of Genesis.

While I am a bit undecided on a few pieces of what this may or may not entail, there are some solid reasons why this is an attractive approach.

1. The doctrine of creation is bedrock in the traditions of Israel, and it would make sense that the story of creation would be overshadowing the narrative of restoration.

2. Apocalyptic typically uses the creation story as a way of pointing to the way creation ought to be - that it was made this way and will eventually return to that way. This also fits into the typical cyclical presentation of history which is also also found in apocalyptic.

3. The images themselves make a point which is doctrinally based upon the creation narrative. This is in some sense a combination of points 1 & 2 above, but is the necessary link to make Dunn's assertion plausible. That man and woman were to be over creation is paralleled in the apocalyptic language of Daniel 7 with the messianic figure rightly ruling over all of the nations.

The parallelism thus works, and there is good reason to see the overshadowing of creation in the restoration narrative of Israel. So I have little problem agreeing with Dunn that this is mostly "an adapted creation myth." But there might be some implications (which I will not take space for here) which I am still working out. But for now, I thought this was a significant piece for restoration theology which might be overlooked (as his footnotes for this section also hint). In the end, the restoration narrative is the retelling and re-achieving of the initial creation. This thread is, I believe, constant throughout Jewish restoration theology.

13 May 2009

Jesus movement: essene or pharisee?

















The chart above (which refuses to be enlarged in blogger for some reason) draws attention to the complexities of Second Temple Judaism. Admittedly, when introducing students to this period I simply cover basic overviews of Pharisees-Sadducees-Essenes-Zealots and do not go into the variations of each. But it is helpful to know that there is a lot more going on than is simply assumed when reading the text. I'll admit: I like this chart - it is a good snapshot of the world of Judaism at this time.

I have one challenge.

My contention with Boccaccini's chart comes down to the emergence of the Jesus Movement. The author's contention is that it emerges out of the Essene group alone. While I am becoming increasingly open to the notion that the Jesus movement looked a lot like Essene Judaism (from delving into Enochic Judaism), I cannot deny that Jesus resembles Pharisaic Judaism as well. In fact, I have heard for many years that "Jesus was a Pharisee" and have myself said that the Pharisees and Jesus were often after the same objectives. (For the record, I cannot hold that Jesus would have been a blanket 'Pharisee' either in card-holding-membership or basic ideology.)

In my estimation (which isn't the most comforting place to theologize, I grant you), the Jesus movement appears to be somewhere between Pharisaic and Essene Judaism of this time period. This is a characterization of theology. Socially, it is much harder to define Jesus - he is somewhere between the Essenes and the Zealots, which doesn't help answer the question at all! But the most significant piece to be gained from this chart is the complexities of Second Temple Judaism and their influence on history and culture - especially Jesus and his followers.

03 June 2008

jonahvangelism

Stephen B. Chapman and Laceye C. Warner, "Jonah and the Imitation of God: Rethinking Evangelism and the Old Testament." Journal of Theological Interpretation 2.1, (2008): 43-69.

This interesting article appeared in the latest issue of the new journal series, Journal of Theological Interpretation.  The premise seems quite straightforward: the Old Testament (especially Jonah) is undervalued in Christian theology, with specific interest in mission and evangelism.  Jonah is a good test case for this as the narrative (and main character) continue to be interpreted in various ways.  The question which is presented by the authors of this article is whether or not Jonah serves as a paradigmatic figure of evangelism within the biblical tradition.  Some say yes, others no (or else we wouldn't have an article, would we?).

In examining Jonah the authors appeal to the narrative focus as a whole, rather than seeing the opening chapter or the closing chapter as disjointed from the rest.  While this sounds simple enough, the extremely well-crafted narrative of Jonah pushes the interpretive limits on this more than one would initially think.  But the authors seem to get it right in both theory and execution.  For the story of Jonah is just that - a story.  And stories are meant to be read/told as whole units, which means our understanding of Jonah and his failures must make sense in light of the whole narrative.  Too many read this story and assume that his running away (ch 1) is because of his lack of faith.  In actuality (as this article points out), his running away is an improper outworking of "too much faith rather than too little" (60)!!  But we are not told this is the case until chapter 4, which allows us to pass judgment upon Jonah before we are able to evaluate ourselves - a maneuver properly identified in Allen's commentary on Jonah.

By the time we reach chapter four we have Jonah sitting on the ground with steam coming out of his ears.  I like the way Chapman and Warner put it: "God skillfully puts Jonah in the position of favoring mercy for a plant in order highlight Jonah's disapproval of mercy for the Ninevites" (58).  Ultimately, what is discovered about the Israelite mission via Jonah is that it envisages both a 'gathering in' and a 'going out' (50) to bring the nations to repentance.  And this seems to be the rub which also leads many exegetes to a break between OT evangelism and NT evangelism.  It is not as though Jonah represents a message only of judgment and destruction while the NT gives only a message of salvation, as Bosch suggests (cf. 44-46).  This is a gross misunderstanding of the Gospels, especially John the Baptist and the role of the Spirit.

Finally, the article notes seven points of which Christians can take Jonah and more adequately fulfill its mission.  The overarching principle is found in the notion that this is God's mission and it is not confined to any of our efforts.  But also, "Christian community extends itself in order to remain itself" (66), which might be the most direct way the narrative of Jonah hits modern evangelicalism between the eyes.

28 February 2008

hypothetical converts


Terence L. Donaldson has published a good work entitled, Judaism and the Gentiles: Jewish Patterns of Universalism (to 135 CE) which surveys the perspective(s) that were held within various Jewish writings (some from communities and individuals as well) regarding the fate of the Gentiles in the final restoration of Israel.  I am still in process of working through the book, so will reserve further comment until a full review can be given.

This morning I was particularly struck, however, with his conclusions regarding Qumran.  It is no secret that this desert community was quite exclusive in their view of salvation, thus driving them to their separatist lifestyle.  In fact, much has pointed to their apparent exclusion of other 
Jewish individuals for their lack of commitment to Torah.  Indeed, a reading through the text clearly leaves a bleak picture for Gentiles.

Yet what Donaldson explores in his examination of their literature is an apparent openness to Gentile conversion and inclusion within their community!  What appears at first to be contradictory is explored further.  The debate itself centers around the identity of the גר in the documents themselves - a debate which Donaldson reviews but does not himself commit to anything further than those people who were not Jewish in their ethnic origin.  And he is probably right to leave it there at this point.  What he discovers, interestingly enough, is that the Qumran texts speak of conversion and posit scenarios of how a גר is brought into the community.

The ins and outs here are fascinating, but can be boiled down quickly to the conclusion which Donaldson reaches: that the apparent contrast between the inclusion of גרימ in Qumran is a matter of belief versus practice.  For, it appears that the community has written about an idealized Israel, ". . .one which included the category of proselytes but as an idealized, hypothetical construct, rather than as a group of flesh-and-blood Gentile converts to Israel."  He further states, "there were proselytes within the Qumran worldview but not within the Qumran community" (215).


And speaking of the church, the more things change the more things stay the same.