Thomas E. Bergler, From Here to Maturity. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2014.
In this final review of Bergler's book we examine the fifth and final chapter, the stated purpose of which is "... to explain a process that congregations can follow to move from where they are to spiritual maturity" (113). Hence, this last piece seeks to set down a foundation for the work of creating an atmosphere in the local church culture where spiritual growth and maturity might take place. The process can be summarized in simple steps: assess, create, implement, monitor. Of course, these are worked out in the chapter itself, but I will not review them in detail here.
One specific area of interest is Bergler's discussion on Maturity on Sunday Morning (120–123). The culture that is created in those things said and done, along with those things not said and done, is crucial to the work of creating an atmosphere of spiritual maturity and growth. This is counter-cultural to many of the trends of modern evangelicalism, which tend to be concerned with entertainment-based appeals to the crowds rather than spiritual discipline. "Although it is probably impossible to eliminate all negative or unintended messages in a congregational culture, it can be valuable to honestly assess what the dominant messages seem to be" (121).
This particular discussion revolves around three central roles that the church's weekly worship gathering has in promoting spiritual maturity (all of these are found on page 122):
"First, the teaching and preaching should regularly mention spiritual maturity."
"Second, the way we teach about worship and the metaphors we use to describe it should promote spiritual maturity."
"Third, the music and the leaders should promote maturity."
In each of these areas Bergler provides good challenge to thinking through the messages we communicate (whether it is our intention or not) during our week worship gathering. At the heart of this challenge is the question to church leaders: Is a steady diet of our church's Sunday morning worship likely to produce a spiritually mature Christian? (123).
So much of what happens in the modern evangelical worship service is individualistic, emotionally-driven, flimsy theology. In many ways the benchmark for Sunday success is set by feelings rather than by the Spirit. And this is why so many people feel as though they need to be "charged" or "refreshed" by their Sunday morning experience, in essence creating an idol from that experience than from the presence of Almighty God. It is the Holy Spirit that empowers the believer, renewing their strength as they wait upon the Lord. No matter how emotional or impressive, there is no experience on earth – church or otherwise – that can replace the deepening relationship of discipleship found in Christ Jesus.
Bergler is good to quote on this point: "Both social-science research and my own observations of Christians immersed in romantic spirituality urge me to conclude that slow-dance worship songs are drawing on American cultural scripts about romantic relationships from their emotional impact ... Too many slow dances with Jesus may reinforce immature forms of the Christian life" (132, bold is mine).
There are ways forward, but they will require a frank and honest look at ourselves, coupled with the determination to make serious change, in the face of those who will kick and scream against such efforts. But if we believe that the major problem is a lack of maturity, then we should not be surprised to be met with adolescent behavior when trying to challenge congregations to grow in their faith. There will probably always be part of us that will long for the days of our youth, but that does not mean it is right for us to hold on to our youthful behavior and ignore the demands of our faith in the present. Parents that do not grow up create children that have no concept of adulthood, and the same is true in our faith: disastrous results will come when we do not make serious disciples of one another in this life – indeed, disastrous results have already taken up residence in our culture.
One of the final challenges that Bergler provides is the (increasingly large) task of reaching into such a broken culture for the sake of the gospel. This will require effort on its own part, for we cannot simply wish these changes into existence. There will be resistance, but not all of it for bad reason. Immature people do not understand the process of growth, and so this can be a daunting and overwhelming path to face. Those who are going to help bring about this type of discipleship will need to work in building these bridges. Bringing people into the faith will require that they find their place in their world, as well as in the church community: "They will need to learn to be bilingual – to speak the language of their own culture, but also the language of Christian faith" (140).
If each person in the local congregation were to take seriously the call of making disciples – the specific work that Jesus gave to his followers – and took the opportunity to play their part in walking alongside one another, then we would see a dramatic impact in the life of the church, and a radical shift in how Christians can impact their world. Discipleship is no quick-fix or relational trend. Discipleship is, as Eugene Peterson would remind us, a long obedience in the same direction.
"he sits enthroned above the circle of the earth, and its people are like grasshoppers"
Showing posts with label from here to maturity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label from here to maturity. Show all posts
08 August 2016
from here to maturity: a discussion 5
04 August 2016
from here to maturity: a discussion 4
Thomas E. Bergler, From Here to Maturity. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2014.
In this next chapter (Chapter Four), Thomas Bergler turns the focus of maturity in the local church to the ministry of younger generations. Youth groups and youth cultures have had an enormous impact on the current state of American evangelicalism, as he has thoroughly reviewed in the first-step in this overarching discussion: The Juvenilization of American Christianity.
At the outset of the discussion the author states the rather vital premise to understanding the dynamics of youth church culture: "No model of youth ministry or set of practices can substitute for a congregation-wide commitment to young people" (82). This is it; here we find the center of the issue of the modern state of the church in regards to it lack of spiritual maturity. For a few generations it has become commonplace for the local congregation to segment off various groups away from the primary work of the body of believers. Nowhere has this been more apparent than with the youth culture.
(However, as this practice has taken root, and time has accompanied the generations of churchgoers to become more comfortable with this, there are now segments of the congregation for every age and stage of life. Conceivably, in a large enough local church, one could go cradle-to-grave without ever making a serious connection with believers who are significantly older, younger, (or in some cases) of a different economic level.)
Not only has this sort of segmentation hurt the unity of believers within the local church, but such an approach has been a primary factor in the lack of maturity among Christians in our culture. Hence, the challenge for the local congregation is to live as one body of faith, working together as a community that is united by the Spirit. From the discussion in Bergler's book it has become apparent that youth can be devoted to their faith without necessarily being found on the path to spiritual maturity (82f.). One wonders if this is a devotion to their particular segment of the local church (the youth group), while never being a significant part of the overall church life – in which case the devotion runs its course as their journey through youth group ends, leaving the average emerging adult without a sense of connection to the ministry of the church.
Yet, the research upon which Bergler draws, "... reveals that American teenagers can become spiritual mature while they are still teenagers" (85, emphasis in original). Those congregations that are engaging their youth into the larger body of believers are the places where one is most likely to find a greater degree of spiritual maturity. It is the integration of youth into the life of the church that helps them bear the marks of spiritual growth and development. The reasons for this should be somewhat self-evident, as the benefit of learning from those who have godly wisdom helps to guide the younger generations into the work and ministry of the local church. Too often this type of wisdom culture is haphazardly shoved to the side in favor of the excitement of a ministry that more readily appeals to the lingering youthful desires in emerging adults.
And yet, feeding these immature desires has just as much of a damaging effect on the individual (and community) as any other behavior or desire. While there is a certain happiness and self-satisfaction derived from a worship experience that is filled with entertainment, in the end it accomplishes little in preparing individuals for the challenges and difficulties of adult life. In other words, a constant youth-emphasis may be fun, but cannot begin to have an impact in a world filled with adult-sized problems.
So, "... because youth are integrated into the congregation, they come to see the church as their church. Young people become active contributors to the church's intergenerational culture of spiritual maturity" (90).
There are many fears that may arise against those who wish to move toward this type of community life. The general fear of losing control over the way things have always been typically arises – and there are endless examples of the next generation of church leadership making radical changes with little-to-no regard for the traditions of this local community. Yet, I wonder if this would not be the case if there was in fact a connection between the generations, where the emerging leaders would already have a knowledge and respect for those things that are truly important to this community. This is not to say that there will never be a need for change (even big change), but rather that the dynamics of such will be tempered by a community that encompasses all believers.
A different type of fear may be that the lack of excitement will lead to a lack of attendance in worship, since this is the music and this is the style that 'reaches young people.' There is little weight that can be given to such an argument, not least of which is that the worship of Almighty God does not need to be dressed up in flashy attire, and all of our attempts to do so look quite pathetic in light of his dynamic presence. Additionally, if the entire discussion about the younger (emerging) generations of American evangelicalism is severely lacking in maturity and belief, then it is somewhat absurd to hold fast to the very system that has facilitated our current dilemma. As the axiom goes, Your current system is perfect for achieving your current result.
There are other fears that we could mention, but they all will fall into the same boat – namely, that there is no room for fear in the ministry of Christ's church. This community ought to be driven by his love, over and against our fearfulness (cf. 1 John 4:18).
Bergler completes this chapter with a focus on the need for serious theological discussion and exploration throughout the church community, specifically for the following two reasons:
1. "... theology provides the basic truths and principles of discernment that every mature Christian must embrace." (112)
2. "... theological reflection can help church leaders identify the barriers to spiritual maturity in their congregation." (112)
Ultimately, this is a discussion about discipleship, which is the work of every believer to engage with every other follower of Christ. If we take this seriously in the working out of our faith, then we will see a significant change in the spiritual growth and maturity of all who participate in our communities of faith. This, I believe, will require a change of direction among individual believers and our interactions with one another, as well as institutional change that better facilitates these aims through the overall structure and mission of the church.
In this next chapter (Chapter Four), Thomas Bergler turns the focus of maturity in the local church to the ministry of younger generations. Youth groups and youth cultures have had an enormous impact on the current state of American evangelicalism, as he has thoroughly reviewed in the first-step in this overarching discussion: The Juvenilization of American Christianity.
At the outset of the discussion the author states the rather vital premise to understanding the dynamics of youth church culture: "No model of youth ministry or set of practices can substitute for a congregation-wide commitment to young people" (82). This is it; here we find the center of the issue of the modern state of the church in regards to it lack of spiritual maturity. For a few generations it has become commonplace for the local congregation to segment off various groups away from the primary work of the body of believers. Nowhere has this been more apparent than with the youth culture.
(However, as this practice has taken root, and time has accompanied the generations of churchgoers to become more comfortable with this, there are now segments of the congregation for every age and stage of life. Conceivably, in a large enough local church, one could go cradle-to-grave without ever making a serious connection with believers who are significantly older, younger, (or in some cases) of a different economic level.)
Not only has this sort of segmentation hurt the unity of believers within the local church, but such an approach has been a primary factor in the lack of maturity among Christians in our culture. Hence, the challenge for the local congregation is to live as one body of faith, working together as a community that is united by the Spirit. From the discussion in Bergler's book it has become apparent that youth can be devoted to their faith without necessarily being found on the path to spiritual maturity (82f.). One wonders if this is a devotion to their particular segment of the local church (the youth group), while never being a significant part of the overall church life – in which case the devotion runs its course as their journey through youth group ends, leaving the average emerging adult without a sense of connection to the ministry of the church.
Yet, the research upon which Bergler draws, "... reveals that American teenagers can become spiritual mature while they are still teenagers" (85, emphasis in original). Those congregations that are engaging their youth into the larger body of believers are the places where one is most likely to find a greater degree of spiritual maturity. It is the integration of youth into the life of the church that helps them bear the marks of spiritual growth and development. The reasons for this should be somewhat self-evident, as the benefit of learning from those who have godly wisdom helps to guide the younger generations into the work and ministry of the local church. Too often this type of wisdom culture is haphazardly shoved to the side in favor of the excitement of a ministry that more readily appeals to the lingering youthful desires in emerging adults.
And yet, feeding these immature desires has just as much of a damaging effect on the individual (and community) as any other behavior or desire. While there is a certain happiness and self-satisfaction derived from a worship experience that is filled with entertainment, in the end it accomplishes little in preparing individuals for the challenges and difficulties of adult life. In other words, a constant youth-emphasis may be fun, but cannot begin to have an impact in a world filled with adult-sized problems.
So, "... because youth are integrated into the congregation, they come to see the church as their church. Young people become active contributors to the church's intergenerational culture of spiritual maturity" (90).
There are many fears that may arise against those who wish to move toward this type of community life. The general fear of losing control over the way things have always been typically arises – and there are endless examples of the next generation of church leadership making radical changes with little-to-no regard for the traditions of this local community. Yet, I wonder if this would not be the case if there was in fact a connection between the generations, where the emerging leaders would already have a knowledge and respect for those things that are truly important to this community. This is not to say that there will never be a need for change (even big change), but rather that the dynamics of such will be tempered by a community that encompasses all believers.
A different type of fear may be that the lack of excitement will lead to a lack of attendance in worship, since this is the music and this is the style that 'reaches young people.' There is little weight that can be given to such an argument, not least of which is that the worship of Almighty God does not need to be dressed up in flashy attire, and all of our attempts to do so look quite pathetic in light of his dynamic presence. Additionally, if the entire discussion about the younger (emerging) generations of American evangelicalism is severely lacking in maturity and belief, then it is somewhat absurd to hold fast to the very system that has facilitated our current dilemma. As the axiom goes, Your current system is perfect for achieving your current result.
There are other fears that we could mention, but they all will fall into the same boat – namely, that there is no room for fear in the ministry of Christ's church. This community ought to be driven by his love, over and against our fearfulness (cf. 1 John 4:18).
Bergler completes this chapter with a focus on the need for serious theological discussion and exploration throughout the church community, specifically for the following two reasons:
1. "... theology provides the basic truths and principles of discernment that every mature Christian must embrace." (112)
2. "... theological reflection can help church leaders identify the barriers to spiritual maturity in their congregation." (112)
Ultimately, this is a discussion about discipleship, which is the work of every believer to engage with every other follower of Christ. If we take this seriously in the working out of our faith, then we will see a significant change in the spiritual growth and maturity of all who participate in our communities of faith. This, I believe, will require a change of direction among individual believers and our interactions with one another, as well as institutional change that better facilitates these aims through the overall structure and mission of the church.
30 June 2016
from here to maturity: a discussion 3
Thomas E. Bergler, From Here to Maturity. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2014.
"A spiritual discipline is something I can do right now which will allow me over time to receive God's grace so that I will be able later to do something I can't do right now" (61).
Within this simple definition of spiritual discipline is the inherent idea that our faith is meant for us to make progress from a particular starting point. Being a disciple is to move, from wherever we find ourselves at a particular moment, towards the cross of Jesus, being conformed to his likeness. From this perspective, it seems that spiritual discipline ought to be desired among every believer (perhaps every person regardless of their faith commitment), for we all wish to become better at living in some capacity. And yet, the current state of the American church shows a culture that has drifted far from this simple discipleship ideal. In this modern quest for a relevant church experience, the measuring stick has become how many people are in attendance more than how many are being made into disciples.
[A slight rabbit-trail from Bergler's discussion: When the church decided to make the gospel more "relevant," does this mean to imply that the gospel had somewhere become irrelevant? Of course not, they would say. It is not about changing the gospel, but about making the church experience of it more relevant than outdated and outmoded forms of worship. And yet, the shifts that have been made from this perspective seem to have changed more of the gospel message than we care to admit – and the primary work of believers to be disciple-makers is at the forefront of this change. But, once again, we are pointed to the "success" of this newer approach in that many people are attending, regardless of the lack of depth in their experience. Perpetual adolescents indeed.]
Chapter Three of Bergler's text is meant to move the discussion forward about how we can approach the current state of affairs and introduce much-needed change. "Although no one intends it, the result can be that the process of spiritual growth seems complicated and possibly even inaccessible" (57). Here is part of the problem of getting back. It is unfortunate that the culture of discipleship in most churches is so lacking and so twisted that the entire notion of spiritual growth is quickly dismissed upon its mention, for that is something that will require too much from me – it is too lofty a goal. Interestingly, there are many within modern evangelicalism who will often speak and sing and tweet about how they have surrendered their whole lives to Christ Jesus, but will scoff at the simplest of commands to come and follow.
The perception that exists is that spiritual discipline is for popes, monks, nuns, and modern-day saints. Beyond this it is simply too high of a plane for the normal person. But even the encouraging words of Moses speak to the heart of our commitment today: Now what I am commanding you today is not too difficult for you or beyond your reach. t is not up in heaven, so that you have to ask, “Who will ascend into heaven to get it and proclaim it to us so we may obey it?” Nor is it beyond the sea, so that you have to ask, “Who will cross the sea to get it and proclaim it to us so we may obey it?” No, the word is very near you; it is in your mouth and in your heart so you may obey it (Deuteronomy 30:11–14). If we truly have a God that seeks to reveal himself to us, to conform us into his likeness, so that we might be everything that he has made us to be – loving us with an everlasting love – then why would we fall for the lie that following hard after him is too much for us to undertake?
One of the keys to spiritual growth in discipleship that Bergler points to in this chapter is that of Vision: not focusing on the means of spiritual growth, but rather keeping the goal as the center of focus (cf. 64f.). When we speak about the processes of discipleship it becomes easy for us to become overwhelmed by the daily work unless we see a particular goal. Nobody begins an exercise regiment for the sake of daily tasks, but rather with a mental image of what results can be achieved with the daily commitment that will be required. These many small steps become compelling only when the overall goal is sketched out in front of the individual. The same is true for any spiritual regiment. We need the small steps of discipleship to make Christlikeness attainable, but we need to the image of the risen Jesus to make discipleship worthwhile.
Without going through the particulars of Bergler's suggested approach(es) in this chapter, let me simply point out that what is being advocated, above all else, in a genuine model of discipleship is a change of heart. This is an essential part of discipleship, initiating the process as well as being the end-result. The commitment of the heart is vital to the success or failure of being conformed to the image of Christ. It is a movement away from ourselves and into the presence of Jesus. Maturity in any area of life is when self-centeredness is abandoned and the giving of the heart is sincere. Marriages that have this succeed every time, while those that do not make this change-of-heart end in failure (and sometimes in divorce).
What is keeping the modern church from developing a mature faith? Only ourselves. To this point we may consider the author's words: "Self-deception often stiffens this resistance to change. We deceive ourselves into believing we love God first when in fact we love several other things just as much" (74). Until this change of heart can be introduced into the experience of the church, a generation of believers will be lost in a sea of immaturity and ineffectiveness. Discipleship demands that Christ Jesus is our one thing – not our one thing more. This self-denial is to be crucified with Christ, and sharing in his risen life.
"A spiritual discipline is something I can do right now which will allow me over time to receive God's grace so that I will be able later to do something I can't do right now" (61).
Within this simple definition of spiritual discipline is the inherent idea that our faith is meant for us to make progress from a particular starting point. Being a disciple is to move, from wherever we find ourselves at a particular moment, towards the cross of Jesus, being conformed to his likeness. From this perspective, it seems that spiritual discipline ought to be desired among every believer (perhaps every person regardless of their faith commitment), for we all wish to become better at living in some capacity. And yet, the current state of the American church shows a culture that has drifted far from this simple discipleship ideal. In this modern quest for a relevant church experience, the measuring stick has become how many people are in attendance more than how many are being made into disciples.
[A slight rabbit-trail from Bergler's discussion: When the church decided to make the gospel more "relevant," does this mean to imply that the gospel had somewhere become irrelevant? Of course not, they would say. It is not about changing the gospel, but about making the church experience of it more relevant than outdated and outmoded forms of worship. And yet, the shifts that have been made from this perspective seem to have changed more of the gospel message than we care to admit – and the primary work of believers to be disciple-makers is at the forefront of this change. But, once again, we are pointed to the "success" of this newer approach in that many people are attending, regardless of the lack of depth in their experience. Perpetual adolescents indeed.]
Chapter Three of Bergler's text is meant to move the discussion forward about how we can approach the current state of affairs and introduce much-needed change. "Although no one intends it, the result can be that the process of spiritual growth seems complicated and possibly even inaccessible" (57). Here is part of the problem of getting back. It is unfortunate that the culture of discipleship in most churches is so lacking and so twisted that the entire notion of spiritual growth is quickly dismissed upon its mention, for that is something that will require too much from me – it is too lofty a goal. Interestingly, there are many within modern evangelicalism who will often speak and sing and tweet about how they have surrendered their whole lives to Christ Jesus, but will scoff at the simplest of commands to come and follow.
The perception that exists is that spiritual discipline is for popes, monks, nuns, and modern-day saints. Beyond this it is simply too high of a plane for the normal person. But even the encouraging words of Moses speak to the heart of our commitment today: Now what I am commanding you today is not too difficult for you or beyond your reach. t is not up in heaven, so that you have to ask, “Who will ascend into heaven to get it and proclaim it to us so we may obey it?” Nor is it beyond the sea, so that you have to ask, “Who will cross the sea to get it and proclaim it to us so we may obey it?” No, the word is very near you; it is in your mouth and in your heart so you may obey it (Deuteronomy 30:11–14). If we truly have a God that seeks to reveal himself to us, to conform us into his likeness, so that we might be everything that he has made us to be – loving us with an everlasting love – then why would we fall for the lie that following hard after him is too much for us to undertake?
One of the keys to spiritual growth in discipleship that Bergler points to in this chapter is that of Vision: not focusing on the means of spiritual growth, but rather keeping the goal as the center of focus (cf. 64f.). When we speak about the processes of discipleship it becomes easy for us to become overwhelmed by the daily work unless we see a particular goal. Nobody begins an exercise regiment for the sake of daily tasks, but rather with a mental image of what results can be achieved with the daily commitment that will be required. These many small steps become compelling only when the overall goal is sketched out in front of the individual. The same is true for any spiritual regiment. We need the small steps of discipleship to make Christlikeness attainable, but we need to the image of the risen Jesus to make discipleship worthwhile.
Without going through the particulars of Bergler's suggested approach(es) in this chapter, let me simply point out that what is being advocated, above all else, in a genuine model of discipleship is a change of heart. This is an essential part of discipleship, initiating the process as well as being the end-result. The commitment of the heart is vital to the success or failure of being conformed to the image of Christ. It is a movement away from ourselves and into the presence of Jesus. Maturity in any area of life is when self-centeredness is abandoned and the giving of the heart is sincere. Marriages that have this succeed every time, while those that do not make this change-of-heart end in failure (and sometimes in divorce).
What is keeping the modern church from developing a mature faith? Only ourselves. To this point we may consider the author's words: "Self-deception often stiffens this resistance to change. We deceive ourselves into believing we love God first when in fact we love several other things just as much" (74). Until this change of heart can be introduced into the experience of the church, a generation of believers will be lost in a sea of immaturity and ineffectiveness. Discipleship demands that Christ Jesus is our one thing – not our one thing more. This self-denial is to be crucified with Christ, and sharing in his risen life.
23 May 2016
from here to maturity: a discussion 2
Thomas E. Bergler, From Here to Maturity. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2014.
One of the challenges that has been presented by Bergler is that "a significant number of Christians do not regard growing up in Christ to be an intrinsic part of what it means to be a follower of Christ" (27). We might be tempted to go even further, especially those of us who have encountered this sort of attitude in the contemporary American church: Do very many Christians even know what it means to be a "mature" follower of Jesus? (that is to say, would they even recognize such language?
The data would certainly suggest that many do not have an adequate understanding of the premise of being a mature Christian, let alone the desire to make such a journey. What is worse yet, there has been a large portion of the American church culture that has been pleased to cater to this shallow faith, rather than pushing believers towards something greater. The answer for this is simply: numbers. Our culture values success that is defined in certain terms, and churches that have big buildings with a lot of people in attendance and a healthy budget fit the American Consumerist version of success, which has been plopped right inside the attitude of the local church despite the gospel's incompatibility with such thinking. To this end many churches have been willing to play their part in the market, designing a church experience that attracts the crowds.
Crowds are easily attracted; disciples are hard to find.
Let's stay with this idea for just a moment: if crowds are the measure of success, then wouldn't the churches around Joel Osteen and Benny Hinn be considered the better congregations of our culture? Doesn't their "success" set a template for how the local church should operate? Indeed, many throughout the years have sought this precise course of action, and most church conferences sell the same message with more evangelical names, but the pattern still exists. There is much to say about church size and church growth dynamics, but my point here is that playing to the crowds does not make for spiritually mature followers of Christ – Jesus himself experienced this when the multitudes had decided to walk away: the closer he came to the cross, the fewer were his companions.
The worst case I have personally witnessed to this phenomenon was a billboard church advertisement I once drove past. It had some cool artwork and flashy design, the name of the church in bold letters across the top, with the promise: WE WON'T TRY TO CHANGE YOU. Now, I don't know what it was that this particular message was intended to answer (it seems to me some issue was in the mind of whoever sent that one through), but my initial reaction to this was, "Then, what's the point?!?"
By contrast, the life of the believer is, by definition, a life of transformation. "The proper response to the good news of the Kingdom of God was to become a follower of Jesus. When Jesus called disciples (followers, students, apprentices), he called them to spiritual transformation" (29). There is an intrinsic summons to becoming in this call, and again Bergler's study here reminds us of Bonhoeffer's famous, "When Christ calls a man, he bids him come and die." As Jesus said, "Whoever finds their life will lose it, and whoever loses their life for my sake will find it" (Matthew 10:39). Becoming a mature follower of Jesus is not an optional add-on for the Christian: "spiritual maturity is central, not incidental, to God's plan" (41).
A fellow from the leadership of a local megachurch once spoke to an acquaintance of mine, claiming that they do not spend much time emphasizing discipleship. When questioned on this, the leader claimed that their church was there to "introduce" people to the gospel, and that that's what they were good at doing, but those who were interested in becoming more seriously committed could choose to pursue such an endeavor on their own desire. In other words, this entire church, considered as a national influence on evangelicalism, is structured to the lowest-common-denominator of the church experience. And they are known for putting on a good show, and having some noted programs. But what is lacking from their community DNA is the transformative experience of the gospel. And, as the data would back up, they have a great number of people in attendance who are not becoming mature Christians.
The need for mature disciples of Jesus within the modern American church is great. "The character qualities that the Holy Spirit produces in the mature follower of Jesus are especially oriented toward building loving human relationships" (43). This is a journey on which every believer may embark, if there is a desire to be a disciple. Those who move in this direction are not without flaw, and they are certainly not perfect (42). (And, for those reading out of a Wesleyan-Holiness tradition, there is room to talk on the use of this word, without contradicting the points made here.)
Bergler suggests that The Shape of Spiritual Maturity is built around three elements: 1) it is desirable; 2) it is attainable; 3) it is visible (48–49). These he fills in with good discussion, but I will not take the time to unpack the details here. Overall, his point is simply, "Far from being the end point of spiritual growth, spiritual maturity is the base camp from which ascent of the mountain of holiness can begin in earnest" (48). I must wholeheartedly agree with this perspective, for the movement towards God is a summons to be like him, which means that we must become less like ourselves – this is sanctification, this is maturity, this is losing one's life in order to find it.
Is this still a possibility for the American church?
Do there remain any disciples who are willing to grow up in Christ Jesus?
One of the challenges that has been presented by Bergler is that "a significant number of Christians do not regard growing up in Christ to be an intrinsic part of what it means to be a follower of Christ" (27). We might be tempted to go even further, especially those of us who have encountered this sort of attitude in the contemporary American church: Do very many Christians even know what it means to be a "mature" follower of Jesus? (that is to say, would they even recognize such language?
The data would certainly suggest that many do not have an adequate understanding of the premise of being a mature Christian, let alone the desire to make such a journey. What is worse yet, there has been a large portion of the American church culture that has been pleased to cater to this shallow faith, rather than pushing believers towards something greater. The answer for this is simply: numbers. Our culture values success that is defined in certain terms, and churches that have big buildings with a lot of people in attendance and a healthy budget fit the American Consumerist version of success, which has been plopped right inside the attitude of the local church despite the gospel's incompatibility with such thinking. To this end many churches have been willing to play their part in the market, designing a church experience that attracts the crowds.
Crowds are easily attracted; disciples are hard to find.
Let's stay with this idea for just a moment: if crowds are the measure of success, then wouldn't the churches around Joel Osteen and Benny Hinn be considered the better congregations of our culture? Doesn't their "success" set a template for how the local church should operate? Indeed, many throughout the years have sought this precise course of action, and most church conferences sell the same message with more evangelical names, but the pattern still exists. There is much to say about church size and church growth dynamics, but my point here is that playing to the crowds does not make for spiritually mature followers of Christ – Jesus himself experienced this when the multitudes had decided to walk away: the closer he came to the cross, the fewer were his companions.
The worst case I have personally witnessed to this phenomenon was a billboard church advertisement I once drove past. It had some cool artwork and flashy design, the name of the church in bold letters across the top, with the promise: WE WON'T TRY TO CHANGE YOU. Now, I don't know what it was that this particular message was intended to answer (it seems to me some issue was in the mind of whoever sent that one through), but my initial reaction to this was, "Then, what's the point?!?"
By contrast, the life of the believer is, by definition, a life of transformation. "The proper response to the good news of the Kingdom of God was to become a follower of Jesus. When Jesus called disciples (followers, students, apprentices), he called them to spiritual transformation" (29). There is an intrinsic summons to becoming in this call, and again Bergler's study here reminds us of Bonhoeffer's famous, "When Christ calls a man, he bids him come and die." As Jesus said, "Whoever finds their life will lose it, and whoever loses their life for my sake will find it" (Matthew 10:39). Becoming a mature follower of Jesus is not an optional add-on for the Christian: "spiritual maturity is central, not incidental, to God's plan" (41).
A fellow from the leadership of a local megachurch once spoke to an acquaintance of mine, claiming that they do not spend much time emphasizing discipleship. When questioned on this, the leader claimed that their church was there to "introduce" people to the gospel, and that that's what they were good at doing, but those who were interested in becoming more seriously committed could choose to pursue such an endeavor on their own desire. In other words, this entire church, considered as a national influence on evangelicalism, is structured to the lowest-common-denominator of the church experience. And they are known for putting on a good show, and having some noted programs. But what is lacking from their community DNA is the transformative experience of the gospel. And, as the data would back up, they have a great number of people in attendance who are not becoming mature Christians.
The need for mature disciples of Jesus within the modern American church is great. "The character qualities that the Holy Spirit produces in the mature follower of Jesus are especially oriented toward building loving human relationships" (43). This is a journey on which every believer may embark, if there is a desire to be a disciple. Those who move in this direction are not without flaw, and they are certainly not perfect (42). (And, for those reading out of a Wesleyan-Holiness tradition, there is room to talk on the use of this word, without contradicting the points made here.)
Bergler suggests that The Shape of Spiritual Maturity is built around three elements: 1) it is desirable; 2) it is attainable; 3) it is visible (48–49). These he fills in with good discussion, but I will not take the time to unpack the details here. Overall, his point is simply, "Far from being the end point of spiritual growth, spiritual maturity is the base camp from which ascent of the mountain of holiness can begin in earnest" (48). I must wholeheartedly agree with this perspective, for the movement towards God is a summons to be like him, which means that we must become less like ourselves – this is sanctification, this is maturity, this is losing one's life in order to find it.
Is this still a possibility for the American church?
Do there remain any disciples who are willing to grow up in Christ Jesus?
18 May 2016
from here to maturity: a discussion 1
Thomas E. Bergler, From Here to Maturity. Grand Rapids: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2014.
In 2012, Thomas Bergler published a historical summary and critique of the adolescent factors that have impacted the contemporary church: The Juvenilization of American Christianity. While the study has gained a good amount of attention, the glaring question that remained following the study was, "Where do we go from here?" Thus, he has published a second volume in the discussion, one that I would like to interact with on numerous points. (The reader will notice that this book was published about two years before this discussion, highlighting the well-known fact among pastors and scholars that you can't always get through your 'book stack' a quickly as you would like.) In 2012 a summary-review of JAC was published on this blog.
In the first volume, Bergler established that, "Beginning in the 1930s and 1940s, Christian teenagers and youth leaders staged a quiet revolution in American church life which can properly be called the juvenilization of American Christianity" (JAC, 4, emphasis in original). Simply stated, this means that a culture-shift began to take place in the generations especially after WWII, changing the way American Christianity is envisioned and put into practice. Although these changes were initiated by those with noble goals and desires, there has been another (mostly unintended) set of consequences: an emerging of Adolescent Christianity, with the expectations that faith ought to be "fun and entertaining" (JAC, 14).
We're All Adolescents Now
With this discussion in mind, Bergler begins this second volume with an outline of the current situation – namely, that we are all caught up in an adolescent Christianity. For those who may have missed the full significance of The Juvenilization of American Christianity, the weight of the current situation is reiterated here. The impact of making Christianity "relevant," especially in playing to the components of youth culture in our society, have been enormous. And this is why discussions around this set of cultural circumstances in the church need to become more frequent, and more serious. "Today, there is less shared understanding of what 'growing up' should include" (4). And, since there is a lack of understanding of what 'growing up' should look like, the church simply isn't seeing much maturity among its membership.
Bergler reviews various factors that impact youth culture and, in conversation with other studies and data, shows that our society is not adequately preparing young people for the demands and responsibilities of adulthood. Even without social-scientific numbers, the casual observer ought to be able to get a sense of anecdotal evidence that this is indeed the case (my observation). In teaching at the college level for the past ten years I have seen many students come vastly ill-prepared for what will be asked of them, often far beyond the scope of academic work. Our nation is seeing an increasing number of young adults who, especially after college, return home, in many cases lacking desire, motivation, or direction to become a responsible adult. What impact is this having on the church? Or, what impact has church-life had on this growing societal trend?
But ours has become a culture of "I'm never going to grow up" rather than stepping up to the responsibilities of living well. In the generations before WWII it was quite common that young boys and girls would take upon the tasks of adulthood for the sake of family survival. In those days a formal education was more of a rarity (no "right" to a college experience), and teenagers were often found taking on the mantle of cultural leadership as quickly as they could – a reflection of the culture. Perhaps there was a bit of growing-up-too-fast mixed in, but if that was the case then the pendulum has definitely swung too far the other direction.
Within the American church this reality is stark: Bergler, citing Smith, refers to modern belief being less of a mature Christianity, and more of a "Moralistic, Therapeutic Deism" (13). Adolescent faith is about emotion and feeling, more than it is about discipleship and transformation. "To keep things in perspective, it is important to note that it is quite amazing that any emerging adults are seriously religious" (15). Indeed, the demands of discipleship are high, but the lack of seriousness by which most within our churches are engaging the endeavor is startling. Bonhoeffer's famous line, "When Christ calls a man, he bids him come and die" seems very much out of place in our context. What is expected of a mature Christian is lost in our culture – left undefined – and therefore an invisible path even to those who appear to be serious about their faith.
And I have seen more than one church that is satisfied with this reality, so long as it means that their numbers and giving are up, claiming that their work is more directed to "introducing people to Jesus" and leaving the work of becoming more serious disciples up to the initiative of the individual (and probably some nod to the prompting of the Holy Spirit, so as to sound spiritual). At the end of the day, this is the culture that defines American Christianity, and the clanging gongs of gifts without the presence of God are becoming deafening and chaotic in our world. What is more, this present generation of American Christianity has now come into its own, and many of our current leaders have never known anything except the entertainment-based, individualistic reassurance that has had such an impact.
"In short, American Christianity looks a lot like we would expect it to look if many Americans were stuck in a Christianized version of adolescent narcissism" (25).
This is a strong challenge, but one that, in many ways, characterizes the current state of the American church. Sadly, the current cycle of political discourse has not only proven this adolescent presence in the church, but has pushed it further along the path – more Christians today seem to be willing to be shaped by culture than by Word and Spirit. This is not the case throughout the world, which is why spiritual revival is happening outside of this country, and a maturing faith is being fostered elsewhere. The Spirit, it seems, will not wait around for us to get on board when there are others who are willing to be participants in the gospel. But adolescents rarely, if ever, see this far beyond themselves.
It is time to move towards maturity.
In 2012, Thomas Bergler published a historical summary and critique of the adolescent factors that have impacted the contemporary church: The Juvenilization of American Christianity. While the study has gained a good amount of attention, the glaring question that remained following the study was, "Where do we go from here?" Thus, he has published a second volume in the discussion, one that I would like to interact with on numerous points. (The reader will notice that this book was published about two years before this discussion, highlighting the well-known fact among pastors and scholars that you can't always get through your 'book stack' a quickly as you would like.) In 2012 a summary-review of JAC was published on this blog.
In the first volume, Bergler established that, "Beginning in the 1930s and 1940s, Christian teenagers and youth leaders staged a quiet revolution in American church life which can properly be called the juvenilization of American Christianity" (JAC, 4, emphasis in original). Simply stated, this means that a culture-shift began to take place in the generations especially after WWII, changing the way American Christianity is envisioned and put into practice. Although these changes were initiated by those with noble goals and desires, there has been another (mostly unintended) set of consequences: an emerging of Adolescent Christianity, with the expectations that faith ought to be "fun and entertaining" (JAC, 14).
We're All Adolescents Now
With this discussion in mind, Bergler begins this second volume with an outline of the current situation – namely, that we are all caught up in an adolescent Christianity. For those who may have missed the full significance of The Juvenilization of American Christianity, the weight of the current situation is reiterated here. The impact of making Christianity "relevant," especially in playing to the components of youth culture in our society, have been enormous. And this is why discussions around this set of cultural circumstances in the church need to become more frequent, and more serious. "Today, there is less shared understanding of what 'growing up' should include" (4). And, since there is a lack of understanding of what 'growing up' should look like, the church simply isn't seeing much maturity among its membership.
Bergler reviews various factors that impact youth culture and, in conversation with other studies and data, shows that our society is not adequately preparing young people for the demands and responsibilities of adulthood. Even without social-scientific numbers, the casual observer ought to be able to get a sense of anecdotal evidence that this is indeed the case (my observation). In teaching at the college level for the past ten years I have seen many students come vastly ill-prepared for what will be asked of them, often far beyond the scope of academic work. Our nation is seeing an increasing number of young adults who, especially after college, return home, in many cases lacking desire, motivation, or direction to become a responsible adult. What impact is this having on the church? Or, what impact has church-life had on this growing societal trend?
But ours has become a culture of "I'm never going to grow up" rather than stepping up to the responsibilities of living well. In the generations before WWII it was quite common that young boys and girls would take upon the tasks of adulthood for the sake of family survival. In those days a formal education was more of a rarity (no "right" to a college experience), and teenagers were often found taking on the mantle of cultural leadership as quickly as they could – a reflection of the culture. Perhaps there was a bit of growing-up-too-fast mixed in, but if that was the case then the pendulum has definitely swung too far the other direction.
Within the American church this reality is stark: Bergler, citing Smith, refers to modern belief being less of a mature Christianity, and more of a "Moralistic, Therapeutic Deism" (13). Adolescent faith is about emotion and feeling, more than it is about discipleship and transformation. "To keep things in perspective, it is important to note that it is quite amazing that any emerging adults are seriously religious" (15). Indeed, the demands of discipleship are high, but the lack of seriousness by which most within our churches are engaging the endeavor is startling. Bonhoeffer's famous line, "When Christ calls a man, he bids him come and die" seems very much out of place in our context. What is expected of a mature Christian is lost in our culture – left undefined – and therefore an invisible path even to those who appear to be serious about their faith.
And I have seen more than one church that is satisfied with this reality, so long as it means that their numbers and giving are up, claiming that their work is more directed to "introducing people to Jesus" and leaving the work of becoming more serious disciples up to the initiative of the individual (and probably some nod to the prompting of the Holy Spirit, so as to sound spiritual). At the end of the day, this is the culture that defines American Christianity, and the clanging gongs of gifts without the presence of God are becoming deafening and chaotic in our world. What is more, this present generation of American Christianity has now come into its own, and many of our current leaders have never known anything except the entertainment-based, individualistic reassurance that has had such an impact.
"In short, American Christianity looks a lot like we would expect it to look if many Americans were stuck in a Christianized version of adolescent narcissism" (25).
This is a strong challenge, but one that, in many ways, characterizes the current state of the American church. Sadly, the current cycle of political discourse has not only proven this adolescent presence in the church, but has pushed it further along the path – more Christians today seem to be willing to be shaped by culture than by Word and Spirit. This is not the case throughout the world, which is why spiritual revival is happening outside of this country, and a maturing faith is being fostered elsewhere. The Spirit, it seems, will not wait around for us to get on board when there are others who are willing to be participants in the gospel. But adolescents rarely, if ever, see this far beyond themselves.
It is time to move towards maturity.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




