Showing posts with label luke-acts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label luke-acts. Show all posts

07 September 2009

definitions

Acts 5:1-11 has a rather 'interesting' scene from the early church - the death of noted members Ananias and Sapphira. I say noted because they are said to have made a name for themselves out of the offering they lay at the feet of the apostles. I say death because that is where they end up. Not that their death has anything to do with the fact that they gave an offering to this upstart movement. Rather, the issue is one of ethics before God - in other words, it is about holiness. Yet, even then most Christians want to avoid this passage because of the seemingly drastic nature of judgment being played out. And you don't typically start introducing the church to non-believers with this passage, that's a bit disconcerting and embarrassing . . . to say the least.

Something that I never caught my eye before a few weeks ago is that the end of this story is the first place that Luke uses the word church to describe this gathering of Jesus-people. One would think that Acts 2, 3, 4 would all be good candidates to introduce this lingo, but Luke waits until the very public death of two figures from within the community to say, 'Yes, this is the church. This is what will fulfill the kingdom of God in a post-Easter world.'

As The Professor (I. H. Marshall) told us, Luke is indeed an historian and theologian. Here we see his theology coming in full force: he knows when to introduce the church and how to introduce the church. Perhaps it is with the same holy fear that gripped the disciples throughout the Easter narrative, when they realized that the world is drastically different, that the new community is caught up in the events of Acts 5. True encounters with the divine are never as ethereal as our dreams would have us to believe; drawing close to God shakes our souls and leave us more than a bit unsettled.

But Luke is clear: this is the church. And now there is a boundary to distinguish between those who want a tingly spiritual experience and those who are committed to the ongoing sacrificial work of the gospel. It would be all-too-easy for this church to be defined around those who were excited and energized in the wake of Pentecost. But time has moved on since that event, and even Acts 5 shows how real life is setting in beyond the mountaintop religious event. Now there are real needs and real challenges, and opportunities for real people to do real kingdom work.

That there is Ananias and Sapphira show that not everyone is going to be in this for the long haul. There have always been (and always will be) people who use this community for their own power and prominence. This road is wide, but it leads to destruction . . . perhaps not in the immediacy seen in Acts 5, but in time which retrospectively looks just as short. Here, just like C. S. Lewis taught us about so many miracles, we have the natural process sped up to an instantaneous event that we might recognize, learn and grow from the truth found in the narrative.

The church is defined in this passage, assuming that you have already been noticing the events of Acts 1-4 (and that you'll keep noticing how the rest of the story plays out). This is not for those looking to make a place for themselves, but for those who sacrifice for the kingdom . . . with great integrity and commitment.

07 August 2009

ascension

Even the light that flows from your hands falls,
bends around a heavy star,
gets trapped making a cavern warm, gutters and
goes out.

But you rise, eternal up-and-gone of human prayer,
you who promise
us a flesh like yours, making light look thick and slow.

For now we have
a body's diurnal dawn and rest, rhythmic like
the rise and fall
of hammer on a nail's head, making our red life
flow like yours.


*Gregory Fruehwirth

11 September 2008

presentee christology

















It has been suggested that much of Luke-Acts (especially Acts) is written with the theological perspective that the early church now has seen Jesus go away and is trying to cope with how this is a supposed *victory* over the world.  In other words, the church must now figure out how the resurrection is meaningful, and how we are going to make it through until the return of Christ back to his people - in which case he will then establish his reign and rule over the world.  This has serious ramifications for our understanding of the text, its historical circumstance, the development of Christian theology, and the manner in which churches are built up in the present.

But this reading, though often prevalent, does serious injustice to what Luke is trying to say in the text.  Luke does not give us an *absentee christology* like so many would like to assert.  This completely misses the portrait which is given through the Gospel, that Jesus' ministry is concerned with the full restoration of Israel and that his resurrection is the definitive act in establishing his vindication to reign over creation.  His ascension in Acts 1 is not the removal of Christ from the church, but his enthronement over the powers which work against God in the world.  And thus he is able to send his Spirit to every believer - building up the church, comforting and guiding in the work of the kingdom, and making his presence available to all creation.

Thus, through the church - the entity which is given as the working of Christ's kingdom in the world - he is establishing his dominion of life and light into death and darkness.  So, it is not as though Luke is scrambling around to construct a theology which will keep his community optimistic about the future.  Instead, he writes a narrative full of discovery that the true reign of God, the fulfillment of the hopes of Israel, have come into the present world (on this, see many works by N.T. "Bishop of Awesome" Wright).  The conflict which comes demonstrates the fulfillment of Israel's covenant (Jervell), but also the battles which serve to define an 'in-between' period before the ultimate realization of the kingdom.

If Jesus is then God's Messiah - the one who has been exalted to share in the power and dominion of Yhwh - then the storyline of Acts is built upon the realization of Israel's restoration has broken into the world.  Acts 3:21 serves to highlight this regarding Jesus: ". . .who must remain in heaven until the time of universal restoration that God announced long ago through his holy prophets."  The fundamental idea of holiness which moves outward from the point of interaction with Yhwh (once the Temple; now the Spirit) continues onward in new profundity along Luke's narrative.

02 May 2008

restoration and division


A classic essay on restoration has recently gained my attention, published in book form as part of Jervell's collection on Luke-Acts.  "The Divided People of God" highlights many of the ins and outs of Jewish restoration and Gentile mission in Luke-Acts and the early church.  Richard Bauckham, in a fabulous essay says, "Jervell convincingly showed that in Acts it is not Israel's rejection of the Gospel that clears the way for the evangelizing of the Gentiles, but rather Israel's acceptance of the Gospel which makes it possible for the Gospel to reach the Gentiles (Richard Bauckham. "The Restoration of Israel in Luke-Acts." In Restoration: Old Testament, Jewish, and Christian Perspectives, ed. James M. Scott, 435-487. Leiden: Brill, 2001. 484, emphasis mine.)

Jervell identifies the restoration of Israel as the primary reason why the mission to the Gentiles can occur.  It is the Jewish acceptance of the gospel which enables Gentile inclusion to the covenant community.  Thus, Luke goes to great lengths to show that not all of the Jews have rejected the gospel message (especially in Jerusalem) and that their division is a sign of the acceptance of the gospel and the fulfillment of the restoration of Israel.  It is this division, reminiscent of Simeon's (although Jervell does not make this explicit connection), which ". . . reveals who really belongs to Israel" (55).

It is a convincing essay overall, with a few details not entirely spelled out - although the seeds are certainly sown.  In regards to the division of Israel he writes, "A conversion of all Israel was not a problem for Luke because it is God's will that some should be excluded.  According to Luke, James can rightly say that the conversion and restoration of Israel can be the basis for the Gentiles' seeking the Lord" (54-55).  At first blush, there appears to be a contradiction of restoration and exclusion as aspects of the will of God.  Perhaps this is why Conzelmann held that it was the repudiation of the Jews which makes the Gentile mission possible, thereby divorcing Christianity from Judaism as a precursor for the outward movement of the gospel.  But if Jervell is correct in what he posits, it is not the exclusion of the Jews which is the thrust of the missionary movement but rather the purification of Israel which fulfills the prophetic expectations for a restored Israel.

It is an interesting perspective on the historical movement of the gospel from Jewish to Gentile circles.  Perhaps many interpreters have viewed Gentile inclusion as assuming Jewish exclusion, which is never explicitly stated in the text.  Jervell states, "The addition of Gentile is part of the restoration of Israel" (60).  If restoration is truly happening among the people of God, then the light to enlighten the nations must shine even more!  Further, M. Fuller ties this event to the ascension of Jesus (in a move inspired by NTW, no doubt) as the final cap on the lordship of the Messiah and the restoration of Israel - though I am yet to be convinced on his views of the Twelve being tied to the land (cf. Michael Fuller, The Restoration of Israel: Israel's Re-gathering and the Fate of the Nations in Early Jewish Literature and Luke-Acts. Berlin: Walter deGruyter, 2006. 263.).

At the end of the day, Jervell has placed the effect of the gospel well within the hopes and expectations of the restoration of Israel that shaped Second Temple Judaism.  Rather than a movement away from Jewish belief, the church fulfills its role as the true Israel which has now been opened up to all.  It is, as Jervell states, ". . . but that the Gentiles have gained a share in what has been given to Israel" (53).

22 February 2008

bringing jesus

Discussions of the Spirit in Luke-Acts have often centered around the concept of δύναμις and its relationship to πνεῡμα.  Graham Twelftree portrays his view of this relationship in his most recent, In the Name of Jesus, when discussing the nature of Christian exorcism and spiritual warfare.  Although he doesn't really bring anything new to the table on the specific relationship of these two concepts, it is interesting how he strings some thoughts together regarding Luke-Acts.

In regards to Luke 5:17 and 8:46 Twefltree makes the statement, ". . .δύναμις works immediately and impersonally, responding to the contact of any believing person without the knowledge or approval of Jesus" (137).  But (and here he moves forward in 'filling-out' this notion), "It is the powerful presence of God's Spirit received for healing through faith" (137).  What Twelftree seems to be saying here is that δύναμις is the outworking of the presence of God's πνεῡμα.  This means, for Luke, that the source of healing is attributed directly to the immediate presence of the Spirit rather than through any incantation or human personality.

While there is definitely more to be said on this idea, what I want to focus on here is how he moves this into the healing and exorcism ministry of the early church.  He states, "From Luke's perspective, early Christian exorcism was successful because the exorcists brought Jesus into the situation either by using his name or issuing a command as if passed down from him" (148, emphasis is mine).  This is an interesting concept which I think has fallen away in the modern church culture.  As people quite obsessed with our own power and influence, we like the concept of δύναμις, regardless of its specific relationship to the Spirit.

Yet, it is quite interesting to note that Luke's picture of δύναμις is predicated on a specific relationship with πνεῡμα - meaning, power comes from a right relationship with the Spirit and not just our desire to have power.  Twelftree's statement refers to the belief among the early Christians that as they invoked the name of Jesus they were introducing the presence of Jesus into the situation.  And this was reserved for the advancement of the kingdom, especially in exorcism, healing and spiritual warfare.  (It is doubtful that parking spaces and vending machine selection warranted such an invocation among the first believers.)

Rather than using 'the name of Jesus' as a way to cap off an otherwise self-centered and egotistic string of wants, the tradition preserved in the Gospel is that the spiritual presence of Jesus held the power of the coming kingdom which was going to overcome the powers of the world.  Therefore, going in the name of Jesus requires the church to go in the full power of the Spirit and the dedication of making the kingdom a reality within the world.  Sadly, this is missing in large part among modern Christians.

"Exorcism was not simply healing a sick person but the bringing of salvation" (148).

18 January 2008

failing to plan is. . .

Presupposition might not be a wonderful thing, but self-recognition of presupposition certainly is.  By this I mean that scholars who write with a self-awareness of their own approach to the text but set it within its proper perspective (not just the false-humility under the pretense of complete objectivity) seem to have a more well-rounded exegesis.  It is fine to presuppose and to come with some conclusions already made, but to complete a study (especially research) these need to be open for reconsideration.  My present grievance is when conclusions are drawn too early in the process of biblical interpretation.

I'm presently working through a thesis for my own doctoral research: Guy D. Nave, The Role and Function of Repentance in Luke-Acts (Atlanta: SBL, 2002).  Admittedly, I don't know much about Nave, so there might be aspects here that are more apparent to others.  I am in the beginning stages of reading through his study, his proposed methodology and such, when I came across some presupposition that seems oddly out of place.

The author states:
Finally, not only is everything that has been accomplished among the author and his reader in accordance with God's divine plan, but God's plan has predestined these events to take place.  In Luke-Acts the plan of God was predetermined by God, and the plan itself has predetermined the events which have taken place (p. 17).

This point is presented quite early in regards to the thesis and seems to shut the door on some other legitimate interpretation before such passages are investigated.  Such an assertion is clearly made to *predetermine* the author's conclusion at the outset of his thesis.  And it is done unnecessarily at this point of Nave's work, when he has made some wonderful comments regarding the nature of narrative and authorial intent.  The fact that there is a plan does not necessitate a comprehensive design of every action - hence, God's exact plan cannot be that things do not work according to his exact plan.  Rather, the notion of a plan among free creatures captures the sentiment much better (as does other, more thoughtful deterministic views).

In the interest of full disclosure, my presupposition is that of a free-will theist.  However, I do not necessarily agree/disagree with an author on this basis; I have found that many scholars from the Reformed camp have made wonderful contributions to the discussion, when they have done so properly.

02 October 2007

re-gathering of israel :1

Michael Fuller’s book, The Restoration of Israel: Israel’s Re-gathering and the Fate of the Nations in Early Jewish Literature and Luke-Acts (Berlin: Walter deGruyter, 2006), examines the motif of exile and restoration as seen through the Jewish hopes of re-gathering as it provides the context for early Christian expectation, especially in Luke-Acts.



In Chapter One Fuller reviews Early Jewish Literature (EJL) and the theme of re-gathering Israel as a part of the eschatological restoration of the nation. He subdivides the chapter into discussions of (1) Israel’s historic re-gathering, (2) future re-gatherings, (3) the re-gathering as return from the Diaspora, (4) the re-gathering of Israel from within Israel, and (5) Philo’s approach to seeing Israel’s return as a symbolic motif of a spiritual journey to God.

The discussion on Israel’s Historic Re-gathering (15-23) focuses primarily upon the prophetic messages of Haggai & Zechariah and Ezra-Nehemiah. Fuller asserts that the message found in these writings suggest a hope of a “greater conclusion” than was experienced in the exilic return from Persia. The return itself seems to have been bound to certain events which helped define the eschatological era - such as the rebuilding of the temple. While Haggai holds to this hope, Zechariah seems to point more toward a greater expectation which came out of the event (16). For Ezra-Nehemiah there are more theological problems which arise from those they encounter in the Land than those who remain in Persia (19). Yet there is still an emphasis on a rebuilt temple as a precursor for that which is to come before the eschatological age. Although Fuller’s thesis is strongly built upon the idea of a specific definition of the re-gathering of Israel, I question his endorsement of Bedford to say that it is not residence in the Land that brings about their legitimate return from exile (20-21), to this point see his discussion on Diaspora. Understanding the issue, this is perhaps still too simplistic a statement as there still seem to be definite ties to the return and re-gathering to the Land (and the temple) which continue to define Israel’s expectations. Interestingly, exile is often seen as a prerequisite rite of passage before the experience of restoration (22).

The next section speaks more directly to the future re-gathering of Israel, in which the motif of exile-return becomes a popular pattern to the notion of restoration (23). Fuller acknowledges the little attention which has been given to the variety of interpretations on this aspect of re-gathering, yet reserves much of his own comment for discussions that will follow.

In exploring the EJL Fuller moves to a discussion of the re-gathering as a return of the Diaspora, an important theme for this topic. There seems to be a distinction between “negative” and “positive” views of the exile. As Jews found themselves in the Diaspora they increasingly found ways to survive and thrive while retaining their own Jewish identity. Consistently, one finds the focus on particular geography as part of the theology and narrative which supports Fuller, “The underlying assumption in these passages is that geography matters, for it is profoundly theological” (26). Ultimately, there is a belief that until everyone who is in exile returns from exile there will be no final restoration of Israel (cf. 26) - even those who remain ‘in the Land’ will be considered in exile.
Out of this, then, emerges the idea that faithfulness is indeed possible while living in the Diaspora, demonstrating the perspective that deliverance might be experienced (28). Furthermore, the nations in which the Jews are scattered have their fate connected with that of those in exile, as Fuller points to from his reading of Tobit 13 (that God “will have mercy unto the nations where you have been scattered”) (29). All of this points toward, contends Fuller, a better and more complete eschatological temple as part of the understanding for restoration and renewal (cf. 31f.). The primary characteristic of this temple (in the context of re-gathering) is that all of the righteous from Israel and the nations will make “pilgrimage to the place of God’s abode” (32).

A similar perspective is seen in Sirach, where Israel is linked closely to the welfare of the other nations and is identified as a source of great beneficial wisdom to the world (34). A point which is slightly different from the overview given of Tobit is that the restoration of Israel comes after the defeat of the nations in Sirach (cf. 37). Although there is the ability to benefit and prosper, to remain faithful to Judaism while in exile, ultimately exile must end for true restoration to occur. This completion of exile comes through the defeat of the nations. Of special note for Fuller is the role of Elijah (41f.). Looking to Elijah, the book of Sirach awaits for the appearance of the prophet at the appointed time to “reestablish the tribes of Jacob.” Thus, tied into the expectations of Israel is the definite appointment of a time when Israel would be restored and re-gathered as an end to exile. The overarching theme, however (here and in Maccabees), is that if there is any portion of Israel which is in exile, then all of Israel is in exile and awaiting an end to the shared condition of the nation (47). In connection to the Abrahamic covenant, there is an integral bond between the people of God and the Land - but perhaps it may be said that a shift was underway about who would occupy the land itself.

The next section of the chapter seeks to explore the question of who would be participating in the re-gathering of Israel. Fuller begins with Wright, who tightly weaves the themes of forgiveness of sins and the end of exile together (cf. 49). Is Wright on the correct path with this? Perhaps, but only if one recognizes that it is not simply equating one with the other; if the exile was a result of Israel’s sin and unfaithfulness then a return from exile would indicate that Israel had been forgiven of their sins. But when Jesus forgives individuals, Wright seems to say that he declares that the exile has/is occuring at present. It is interesting to consider when Jesus marked the return from exile - different scholars have different points of view.

A distinct development within the theme of re-gathering, which Fuller addresses, is that a marking of of Israel from within Israel begins to occur - the developing remnant theology of those who will return from exile (cf. 51f.). Fuller examines the Damascus Document to illustrate the notion of a ‘true return from Babylon’ where those who are returning are recounted in light of their exile to demonstrate a redemptive value of their return (55-60). This ties into the theme mentioned above that an experience of exile was somewhat expected in order for true restoration to occur. Further demonstrating this is Fuller’s examination of the Animal Apocalypse of 1 Enoch, where God’s withdrawal from Israel is a key portion of the story (cf. 62f.). This will lead to the destruction of Jerusalem and the temple and demonstrate that Israel’s geo-political problems have a heavenly origin as her unfaithfulness leads her to exile. This, however, is seen by Fuller to be a negative counterpart for the positive portion of re-gathering (69), perhaps interpreted in a more deterministic outlook since he mentions how the nations receive no eternal judgment within the account (71). One cannot help but wonder if this point is indeed accurate to the general belief of Israel, since the destruction of the nations remains such a powerful idea.

What is seen quite clearly is the destruction of the designation between Jew and Gentile. This has been abandoned for a clearer picture of the true people of God who emerge from exile. Thus, the exiled tribes are not “lost” (75) in the sense that they can achieve faithfulness and participate in the re-gathering. The remnant becomes representative of all Israel and indicates the (small) faithful who will be gathered at the messianic age (78-79). When the messiah comes to Israel, he achieves victory as the nations are destroyed - brought about by his re-gathering of Israel over the nations which had kept Israel in exile (cf. 82). What restoration ultimately means - coming out of this discussion - is the “imminent appearing or uncovering of what is already present in Ezra’s time” (83). The ultimate establishment of that which Israel already confesses: the reign of God over his people and his kingdom.

At this point, Fuller discusses the nuanced approach of understanding exile given by Philo. He mentions up front that his notion is not necessarily representative of the nation of Israel as a whole, but is nevertheless important to the development of Jewish exilic and restoration thought. Since I agree that Philo is quite nuanced in his approach and understanding, I will skip over this section of the chapter for the present and will return to Philo in a later post.

More than a political and geographic problem, the exile of the Israel was a spiritual problem which was to expected to be solved with the return and re-gathering of the true Israel. Chapter Two of Fuller’s study, “The Fate of the Nations and Other Enemies,” will be reviewed shortly.